Popcorn Panel: 'Amelia'

Get to the Theater

"Amelia" soars as the story of a pioneer who paved the way for women to be accepted as female pilots. She resisted permanent commitments. Flying to her was an extension of that feeling of being free. Hilary Swank is able to reveal all the complicated layers of this extraordinary woman. In addition, there's a striking resemblance to the real Amelia that adds another dimension to this story. Richard Gere plays her husband, watching from the sidelines, as she went on her dangerous flights. I hope the Motion Picture academy remembers and rewards Swank for her performance; she's that good!

Linda Adams,

Naperville resident

Wait for the DVD

The life of Amelia Earhart is certainly more fascinating than anticipated. The movie captures her pioneer spirit and highlights her groundbreaking work on behalf of women. Actress Hilary Swank becomes Amelia. However, the story never really takes off, and most of the footage is about as interesting as a travelogue, which for me is not that uplifting. But it is educational and perhaps a little bit inspirational. Imagining what really happened to the media darling on her last voyage is irresistible but not enough for an entire movie. In short, this film is better suited for the History Channel.

Phil Norton,

Naperville resident

Skip It

This film was doomed from its start, which was abrupt, leaving the viewer completely disconnected from the portrayals of the people this was based on. Although with how elementary and uninteresting the performances were, we may be better off. The script is empty other than flights and poorly delivered "Hallmark" sentiments, leaving out any real substance to make this story something to care about. Mira Nair worsens this by directing the film with no finesse, driving it to a cluttered collection of scenes. The story of Amelia Earhart is one that has intrigued people for decades, and this film makes one question if it really should.

Bill Stetson,

Naperville resident